NYCCELP v. Vallone

New York City Coalition to End Lead Poisoning et al. v. Vallone et al.
Documents available (in PDF format, click here for more information)

Supreme Court Decision October 11, 2000, striking down Local Law 38 ( in HTML or PDF format )

Appellate Division Appeal documents and decision reversing Supreme Court judgment and reinstating Local Law 38

Court of Appeals documents and decision of July 1, 2003, reversing Appellate Division and re-instating Supreme Court judgment. striking Local Law 38

Documents in Supreme Court

Pleadings and Briefs	Expert Affidavits & Affirmations	Other Affidavits & Affirmations
Order to Show Cause	Dr. Charles E. Gilbert	Matthew J. Chachère (Initial) (Lists the supporting exhibits)
Petition and Complaint	Dr. Bruce P. Lanphear, M.D	Matthew J. Chachère (Reply) (Lists additional exhibit)
Memorandum of Law	Dr. Philip J. Landrigan, M.D.
Reply Memorandum of Law	Dr. Herbert Needleman, M.D.
	Dr. Irving Mauss, M.D.
	Dr. Evelyn Mauss
	Dr. John F. Rosen (Initial)
	Dr. John F. Rosen (Reply)
	David Newman
	Edward Olmsted, C.I.H.
	Robert Friedl

Correspondence with City on the Judgment and the "Stay" issue

Documents on City's March 13, 2001, Motion to Stay Judgment:

City's Motion for Stay:	NYCCELP's Opposition:
Notice of Motion	Notice of Cross Motion
Affirmation of Mark Muschenheim	Affirmation of Theodora Galacatos
Affirmation of Harold Schultz (HPD)	Affidavit of Dr. Evelyn A. Mauss
Affidavit of Jessica Leighton (DoH)	Affidavit of Dr. Martin Rutstein
Affidavit of Joseph Strassburg (Rent Stabilization Association)	Affidavit of Mary Gearhart
Affidavit of Nick LaPorte (Association of Builders and Owners of Greater New York)	Memorandum of Law
Affidavit of Dan Margulies (Community Housing Improvement Program, Inc.)
Affidavit of Steven Spinola (Real Estate Board of New York)
City's Reply Papers	NYCCELP's Reply Papers
Reply Affirmation of Mark Muschenheim	Reply Affidavit of Dr. Evelyn A. Mauss
Reply Affidavit of Jessica Leighton (DoH)	Reply Affidavit of Dr. Martin Rustein
Reply Affirmation of Harold Schultz (HPD)	Reply Memorandum of Law
Decision of Appellate Division (May 10, 2001) denying automatic stay, granting discretionary stay of enforcement, and expediting appeal

Appellate Division Documents

City's Brief	NYCCELP's Brief
City's Reply Brief	NYCCELP's Brief
Friends of the Court brief by Real Estate lobby in Support of City	NYCCELP's Opposition to Real Estate Lobby's Friends of the Court Brief
	Friend of the Court Brief of New York State in support of NYCCELP
	Friends of the Court Brief by Doctors and Lead Poisoning Prevention Experts in support of NYCCELP
Decision of Appellate Division reversing Supreme Court and reinstating LL 38 (March 26, 2002)

Motion to Appellate Division for Leave to Appeal to the Court of Appeals

City's Opposition to Motion for Leave to Appeal to the Court of Appeals	NYCCELP's Brief to the Appellate Division in Support of Leave to Appeal to the Court of Appeals
	NYCCELP's Reply Brief on Motion to the Appellate Division for Leave to Appeal to the Court of Appeal
Decision of the Appellate Division denying leave to appeal to the Court of Appeals (July 25, 2002)

Motion for Leave to Appeal to the Court of Appeals

City's Opposition to Motion for Leave to Appeal	NYCCELP's Brief to the Court of Appeals for Leave to Appeal
	Environmental Groups and Children's Organizations Friends of the Court Brief in support of NYCCELP's motion for Leave to Appeal
	Doctors and Lead Poisoning Prevention Experts' Friends of the Court Brief in support of NYCCELP's motion for Leave to Appeal
Decisions of the Court of Appeals granting leave to appeal and granting leave to file amicus briefs (Nov. 21, 2002)

Court of Appeals Documents

City's Brief to the Court of Appeals	NYCCELP's Initial Brief to the Court of Appeals
Real Estate Lobby Friend of the Court Brief in support of City	Environmental Groups and Children's Organizations Friends of the Court Brief in support of NYCCELP
	Friend of the Court Brief of New York State in support of NYCCELP
	Friends of the Court Brief by Doctors and Lead Poisoning Prevention Experts in support of NYCCELP
	NYCCELP's Reply Brief
Decision of the Court of Appeals

documents in NYPIRG v. Vallone , New York Public Interest Research Group's challenge to LL38